Benchmarking across dental practices: how to compare clinics within a group
How to compare dental clinic or dental chain locations: key metrics to use, how to normalize data, Italian benchmarks, and how to address performance gaps.

Benchmarking between dental locations: how to compare clinics within a group
Benchmarking between dental locations means comparing clinics within the same group using the same indicators, calculated in the same way, to understand which location performs better and why. This way, best practices from one location can be transferred to the others. All it takes is a few numbers: chair utilization, missed appointments, treatment plan acceptance rates, hourly yield, and collections versus turnover. These numbers must be adjusted for the size and patient mix of each location, and they must be extracted from uniformly recorded data. In this guide, you will find which indicators to use, how to make them comparable, what external benchmarks exist in Italy, and how to turn a variance into a decision.
TreatbaseMore uniform data across locationsTreatbase brings together invoices, procedures, and reminders in a dental management software, offering useful tools to compare group data.Discover Treatbase
In brief
Benchmarking across locations only works if all clinics record procedures, times, and collections using the same rules and fee schedule.
To get started, 6–8 indicators are enough. Chair time is the most useful, as procedure costs, hourly profitability, and utilization all depend on it.
A two-chair clinic in a retiree neighborhood cannot be compared "raw" to a five-chair clinic in the city center: the numbers must be normalized first.
Italian external benchmarks (ANDI surveys and ISA synthetic tax reliability indices for dental practices) help provide context. They do not replace internal comparison.
The goal is not to rank dental directors. It is to find where in the process time and margins are being lost.
Table of Contents
What benchmarking means in a dental group
Why comparing locations matters more today
Key indicators to include in the dashboard
Normalizing data: comparing genuinely comparable locations
Italian sources for external comparison
Before the numbers: clean, uniform data
From comparison to action: a six-step method
Our point of view
Management software designed for multi-location groups
Frequently asked questions
Sources
What benchmarking means in a dental group
In a group, benchmarking serves as horizontal management control. While an individual practice compares itself against its past, a group compares its locations against one another at any given time. As noted in an in-depth analysis by Odontoiatria33, consistently monitoring practice data makes it possible to analyze effectiveness and efficiency and to plan management strategies. With multiple locations, this advantage multiplies because each clinic becomes a benchmark for the others.
There are two levels of comparison:
Internal benchmarking: location against location, using the same indicators and the same time period. This is the most reliable, since the management software, price list, and clinical protocols are identical.
External benchmarking: the group, or an individual location, compared against industry averages. This is useful for understanding whether an issue affects only your practice or the entire profession. It is less precise because averages bundle very diverse organizations together.
A group with three or more locations should start with internal comparison and use external data to provide context.
Why comparing locations matters more today
The market is pushing toward consolidation. The ANDI 2024 economic analysis describes the solo-practitioner model in decline, weighed down by financial and bureaucratic burdens and an aging workforce. In 2022, dentists aged 60 or older accounted for 29.7% of the total, compared to 8.9% in 2011. Many practices are being acquired, merged, or absorbed into larger networks. Those opening a second or third location today often inherit disparate systems, habits, and price lists.
Margins have also tightened. According to ANDI, revenues resumed growth in 2023, but profits were squeezed by rising energy and operational costs. For 2025, the ANDI Study Center reports that 52.6% of dentists saw operating expenses increase while fees remained largely flat. If prices cannot be raised, margins can only be recovered through efficiency: more productive chair hours, fewer gaps in the schedule, and fewer abandoned treatment plans. Cross-location benchmarking reveals exactly where to act.
Key indicators to include in the dashboard
No one reads a dashboard with thirty metrics. To start, six to eight indicators are enough, selected from those that Odontoiatria33 highlights as the fundamentals of practice analysis: number and type of procedures per provider, production value, procedure and wait times, and acceptance rates. Here is the set we recommend for a multi-location group.
Indicator | How it is calculated | What it reveals | Typical mistake |
|---|---|---|---|
Chair utilization | Booked hours ÷ available chair operating hours | Unused clinic capacity | Counting booked hours instead of actual completed chair hours |
Hourly chair yield | Production for the period ÷ chair hours worked | Real productivity, normalized for infrastructure | Dividing by open hours rather than hours actually worked |
Missed appointments | No-shows without notice ÷ total scheduled appointments | Quality of recalls and appointment confirmations | Lumping cancellations with notice together with no-shows |
Treatment plan acceptance | Accepted plans ÷ presented plans (by count and value) | Effectiveness of diagnosis and communication | Looking only at the number of plans, not their monetary value |
New patients | First visits of the month, by acquisition channel | Patient acquisition capability | Counting returning patients after several years as new patients |
Recall continuity | Attending recall patients ÷ due recall patients | Patient retention and scheduled workflow | Failing to distinguish between hygiene visits and routine checkups |
Collections over revenue | Period collections ÷ period invoiced revenue | Quality of administrative management | Overlooking ongoing patient financing plans |
Production per provider | Value of procedures per clinician and hygienist | Team organization and provider mix | Using it to judge individuals rather than the system |
Time as the primary indicator
If you had to choose just one metric, choose time. The same Odontoiatria33 article identifies it as central, because time dictates procedure costs, hourly profitability, assistant utilization, overhead burden, and chair occupancy. Between locations, the difference rarely lies in the fee schedule. It lies in the minutes: a clinic that takes 20 minutes longer for the same initial consultation loses hours every week that no financial report makes visible.
Leading vs. lagging indicators
Quarterly collections arrive when it is already too late to course-correct. By contrast, schedule occupancy for the next four weeks, open treatment plans, and upcoming recalls anticipate what will happen. A good group dashboard combines both: lagging indicators for the monthly review, and leading indicators for the weekly meeting with clinic managers.
Normalizing data: comparing genuinely comparable locations
This is where most groups go wrong. Locations are not identical, and comparing absolute numbers simply rewards the largest clinic, not the most efficient one.
A rigorous approach comes from public healthcare. In the statistical methods of the National Outcomes Programme (PNE), Agenas explains that to compare facilities or geographical areas, one must account for differences in patient populations (age, gender, clinical complexity, comorbidities) and apply risk-adjustment techniques. Agenas also distinguishes between two denominators: population-based, to compare geographic regions, and workload-based, to compare healthcare providers. For a dental group, the exact same principle applies.
The four adjustments to apply
Size: calculate metrics per dental chair and per chair hour, never on location totals. A clinic with five chairs will inevitably generate more turnover than one with two.
Specialty mix: a clinic with a full-time implantologist has a completely different hourly yield than one focused on operative dentistry and hygiene. Compare locations by clinical area (hygiene, operative, endodontics, prosthetics, implantology, orthodontics), not just across aggregate figures.
Catchment area and demographics: average age, the share of patients using insurance or dental plans, and local purchasing power directly impact treatment plan acceptance. A 55% acceptance rate in a working-class suburb may be a better performance than 65% in a downtown center.
Location maturity: a clinic that opened or was acquired less than two years ago is still building its active patient base. Compare it with other clinics during their first or second year, not against a flagship practice.
Once normalized, the numbers often change drastically. You may discover that the "worst" location actually yields the highest return per chair hour, and that its only real issue is an empty schedule on Monday mornings.
Italian sources for external comparison
In Italy, there is no public database covering clinical and operational KPIs for dental practices. However, several reliable benchmarks do exist:
ANDI economic trend analyses. Every year, the Italian Dental Association publishes a study on the state of the profession, detailing collections, overhead, patient volumes, and organizational models. These are invaluable for determining whether a downturn in your group is an isolated issue or an industry-wide trend. For up-to-date data, refer to the latest ANDI report page and subsequent editions.
Synthetic tax reliability indices (ISA). For the 2023 tax year, ISA DK21U applies to dental practices and dental enterprises; its estimation models also incorporate bank interest rates and ISTAT indices, as detailed in the Italian Revenue Agency presentation. Your accountant can use these for high-level financial comparisons. However, they remain a tax compliance tool and reveal nothing about scheduling or case acceptance.
Industry surveys conducted by trade associations and dental market observatories. These are helpful for macro market trends, but less useful for operational comparisons.
All share the same limitation: they are national averages. When deciding how to organize your clinic in Monza versus the one in Bergamo, the only truly actionable data is your own.
Before the numbers: clean, uniform data
A benchmark is only as reliable as the underlying data. As Odontoiatria33 cautions, analyses become unreliable if data is imprecise, incomplete, or inconsistently coded. In groups formed through acquisitions, the problem is almost always the same: each location runs its own software, uses its own clinical nomenclature, and sets its own pricing.
Before comparing, ensure these fundamentals are aligned:
A standardized fee schedule and procedure list. A "hygiene session" must share the same code, standard duration, and list price across all locations, or feature clearly documented variations.
Unified calendar rules. Standardize what counts as a no-show, the required advance notice for cancellations, and how emergency appointments are logged.
Chairside chart completion during the visit. If charts are filled out at the end of the day from memory, recorded procedures and timings will diverge from reality. Often, the busiest clinic has the least accurate records.
A single invoicing and billing source. Invoices, deposits, and patient financing must flow through the same system; otherwise, the collection-to-revenue ratio cannot be compared.
Clearly defined roles and permissions. Clarify who can modify a treatment plan, who can issue a discount, and who has visibility into the financial data of other locations.
From comparison to action: a six-step method
If benchmarking does not lead to decisions, it remains an empty exercise. Management experts recommend continuous monitoring of variances between planned and actual figures to drive decisions on workflows, pricing, overhead, organization, and staffing. This mirrors the logic of the National Outcomes Programme (PNE), which analyzes process and outcome variability to guide clinical and operational audits.
Set a target per location, normalized for chairs, clinical mix, and maturity. A blanket target across all locations does not work.
Review variances monthly with clinic managers in a focused 30–45 minute meeting using the exact same dashboard.
Focus on a single variance at a time, prioritizing the one with the greatest financial impact.
Pinpoint the root cause within the process: low acceptance might stem from the lack of a dedicated treatment plan presentation visit. High no-shows might be caused by missing reminder messages the day before.
Replicate the best-performing clinic's practice across other locations, assigning an owner and a review date.
Re-evaluate after 60–90 days and decide whether to establish the new practice as a standard operating procedure for the group.
A practical example
Consider a hypothetical three-location group. Location A, the flagship, achieves the highest hourly yield. Location B leads in treatment plan acceptance. Location C, recently acquired, struggles with low chair occupancy and frequent no-shows. Without normalization, Location C simply looks like the "underperformer." However, comparing by indicator reveals that Location C does not send automated appointment confirmations and its recall system has been stalled for months. The first corrective action is operational, not commercial: set up automated reminders and reactivate overdue recalls. Only then does it make sense to focus on case acceptance, using Location B’s presentation workflow as a model.
Our point of view

We see many dental groups eager to benchmark their clinics only to stall at the exact same obstacle: the data is not comparable because each location records it differently, and often too late. We believe the root issue occurs well upstream of reporting. If dentists or hygienists have to transcribe clinical records by hand at the end of the day, data gets missed, real chair times go unrecorded, and the dashboard portrays a practice that does not reflect reality.
That is why we focus on data capture at the source. When clinical charting is completed by voice during the appointment—including hands-free periodontal charting—the data is captured completely and standardized identically across every location. At that stage, standardizing clinical charts and billing across clinics stops being a daunting separate initiative: it simply becomes the natural way of working. Cross-location benchmarking then becomes what it was always intended to be: a way to spot operational bottlenecks, rather than a surveillance tool for staff.
— Matteo
Management software designed for multi-location groups
Treatbase is a cloud-based dental practice management platform featuring voice-powered AI, engineered for solo practices and multi-location groups alike. Clinical records and billing follow uniform rules across all clinics, performance analytics enable direct comparisons, automated reminders curb no-shows, and granular role permissions control access across the network. If your locations currently use different software, data migration is completely free, and the platform supports multiple languages for groups operating internationally. Discover how Treatbase dental management software can support your practice.
Frequently asked questions
What is a benchmarking study in dentistry?
It is a systematic comparison between the performance of a practice—or clinics within a group—and an established baseline: sister locations, past historical performance, or industry averages. It relies on metrics calculated uniformly, such as chair utilization, hourly yield, and case acceptance rates. The objective is to identify top-performing workflows and roll them out across the group.
How many locations are needed for benchmarking to be useful?
Internal comparison is valuable with as few as two locations, provided both capture data using identical guidelines. With three or more locations, recurring patterns emerge, making it easier to distinguish between an isolated clinic issue and a group-wide challenge. A single practice can benchmark against its historical data and industry standards.
How often should locations be compared?
Leading indicators, such as future schedule occupancy and outstanding treatment plans, should be reviewed weekly. Lagging indicators, like hourly yield, collections, and acceptance rates, should be reviewed monthly in a brief meeting with clinic managers. Targets and normalization adjustments for size and specialty mix should be reviewed quarterly.
Can Italian ISA indices be used as a practice benchmark?
ISA indices offer a high-level fiscal and financial baseline suitable for discussions with your accountant. However, they do not measure chair utilization, appointment duration, or clinical workflow efficiency, making them inadequate for making operational decisions. Use them for broad economic context alongside your internal data.
Sources
Odontoiatria33: turning practice data into actionable management insights
ANDI: 2024 economic analysis on the state of the dental profession
Agenas: statistical methods of the National Outcomes Programme (PNE)
Italian Revenue Agency: presentation of ISA synthetic tax reliability indices for tax year 2023